{{rh_onboarding_line}}
👋 Hey!
Simon Harper's dashboard looked healthy. Over the last 12 months, All About Email gained subscribers, opens ticked up, and earnings grew.
One number was heading the other way. His click rate was down 14.9%.
So he pulled two years of sends to find out why, and published everything he found, mistakes included. He still doesn't have a neat answer. That turned out to be the useful part.
This week: beehiiv starts sending from its own servers, Microsoft has a very rough week, a playbook for taking your newsletter offline, and a subject line that looked unfinished and nearly doubled clicks.
Let's dive in! 👇
Meme of the Week

This Week's Hot Takes
beehiiv built its own sending engine, and a send to 1 million subscribers now takes about 16 seconds. beehiiv Hex runs on IPs beehiiv owns, shared only with the top 1% of senders, and 99.1% of its mail gets accepted by inbox providers.
Microsoft bounced mail from domains without DMARC for a weekend, then went down for most of a day. Adding DMARC is a good idea, however small you are, and check for Microsoft addresses suppressed on November 12 or 13. Ask your platform to reactivate them.
Substack's new design tools give your site seven themes and custom fonts. Play in the Mini-Editor, then fine-tune your Home, Welcome and Post pages in the Full Editor. The Substack app keeps its own layout, so app readers won't see it.
The Bulwark handed all its ad sales, newsletters included, to Vox Media for three years. It's on track for $30M+ this year, split roughly evenly between ads and subscriptions, with 147,000 paid subs on Substack. Publisher and CEO Sarah Longwell calls its inventory undermonetized.
Ghost now lets you store each member's company, neighborhood or interests. Add Custom Fields in Settings, filter your members list by any of them, and make a field public so readers update it themselves from Portal. CSV imports work too.
Let the draft come to you.
Pick your issue days, a time, a timezone. On schedule, HeyNews drafts the next issue from the stories your sources turned up, in the voice it learned from your archive. You get a notification when it's ready. Then it waits in Issues until you review it, because automated drafts are never sent or published on their own.
Tool of the Week
Botsify: an AI agent that fields reader questions and sponsor leads for you
Why You’ll Love It: Describe your agent in one sentence and Botsify writes the system prompt, then indexes your PDFs, URLs and Google Drive files so it answers from your own material. Feed it your media kit and FAQ, and it handles repeat questions and qualifies sponsor leads on your site, WhatsApp, Instagram, Messenger and SMS. Connect Calendly, and good leads book a call while you’re busy writing.
Best For: Operators buried in DMs and “what are your ad rates?” emails, plus agencies that run newsletters for clients: the white-label setup uses your domain and logo with no “powered by” badge, so you can resell agents as your own.
Growth Hack of the Week
Host a meetup built like your best issue
How: Start small. Mark Hurst, who runs Creative Good, suggests an informal meetup at a local coffee shop, then see who shows up. Chatwan Mongkol launched Soiciety, a Bangkok newsletter, and hosted his first community walk nine months later. He now plans each walk like an article, with a narrative arc, some tension and questions people take home. On one, readers stood at Makkasan junction, an intersection he'd covered after a deadly train-and-bus collision, and watched separate agencies run it in real time. Announce the event in your newsletter, then list it on Meetup or Luma too. Organizer Sia Karamalegos says a lot of attendees find events there. Unsure anyone will come? Isabelle Amazon-Brown tested interest with a Reddit post before launching Norwich Tech for Good. And if your readers are spread across the globe, run it online.
Why: A meetup turns a one-to-many list into people who know each other, and it shows you what's landing. Writer Cara Kuhlman says walking-tour attendees reveal which topics resonate with her readers. Events can also feed your paid tier: Soiciety's paid subscribers get into events free, and free subscribers can buy a ticket. Both routes fund the journalism.
Expected Result: Hurst estimates about half the attendees at his revived GEL conference bought tickets because of his newsletter emails. Buttondown's Matthew Guay, who rounded these stories up, has no revenue numbers for the smaller meetups, so treat this as a playbook. Your first one can be tiny. Guay met Mongkol on a walk with eight other readers, and a monitor lizard stalked their path.
Spotlight: All About Email by Simon Harper
What works:
He audits his own numbers in public. Over 12 months, his dashboard showed active subscribers up 5.9%, opens up 1.5% and earnings up 2.4%. Click rate fell 14.9%. Issue #265 walks readers through two years of sends to explain the gap.
He checks the math before blaming the content. Raw unique clickers barely moved, from about 44 to 46 per issue, while recorded opens grew from about 301 to 372. Same clickers, bigger denominator. Then he split the latest year using beehiiv's verified clicks, which filter out security bots that click links automatically. Verified clickers dropped from about 43 per issue (November to April) to 29 (May to November), with opens flat.
He logs his own mistakes as variables. A list clean-up in August 2025 cut recipients from 657 to 538 in one send. In May, a change to his re-engagement trigger hit existing subscribers immediately. Both reshaped the audience, so he treats those periods as different lists.
He reads topic results as questions. Practical issues on BIMI and Gmail address changes drew 58 and 59 verified clickers.
Creator quote: "What I wouldn't do is remove subscribers simply to improve the percentage." Simon Harper, creator, All About Email
Your takeaway: When your click rate drops, pull raw clickers per issue first, then split the year in half and mark every list change on the timeline. Track verified clicks against delivered emails, and ask readers what they get from the email itself. Prune your list only once the numbers give you a real reason.
A/B Test of the Week
Test: Fundraising research firm NextAfter sends a biweekly digest of links and resources for nonprofit marketers. Its subject lines usually spell out the payoff, and the control in this test did exactly that, promising four free resources to help readers finish the year strong. The treatment looked like a note the team forgot to delete: a bracketed placeholder that opened with "[Insert Interesting, Compelling Year-End". Same sender, same preview text.
Result: Opens rose from 23.8% to 27.7%, a 16.3% relative lift at 100% confidence. Clicks jumped 93.3%, and click-to-open rate climbed 63.8%. The test needed 978 recipients to be valid and got 14,079.
Takeaway: A subject line that breaks your usual pattern gives regulars a reason to look twice, and NextAfter's team credits the humor more than the brackets. The lift carried all the way to the click, so readers who opened out of curiosity stayed curious. Caveats: one organization, one send from December 2020 (before Apple's Mail Privacy Protection muddied open rates in 2021), and a gag like this wears out fast if you repeat it. Save it for a send with something worth clicking.
Quick Links
Questions? Just write a comment below. We read all the comments and respond to them.
Thanks for reading,
Eren & Cagri

